Is Rishi Sunak the right person to lead the UK?

Rishi Sunak has secured the backing of Conservative Party MPs to become the United Kingdom’s new prime minister.

The 42-year-old’s rival, Penny Mordaunt, withdrew on Monday from the internal Tory leadership contest to succeed Liz Truss, who resigned last week after just six largely chaotic weeks in office.

Truss’s predecessor, Boris Johnson, considered making a comeback but withdrew from the race on Sunday evening.

Sunak‘s win, less than two months after losing out to Truss in the previous contest, means that he is set to make history on Tuesday when he formally becomes prime minister, the first non-white person to hold the post.

In his first public remarks as the new leader, Sunak said: “It is the greatest privilege of my life to be able to serve the party I love and give back to the country I owe so much to.”

Born in the southern English city of Southampton to Hindu parents of Indian descent, Sunak is one of the UK’s wealthiest politicians. Prior to entering parliament for the first time in 2015, Sunak worked for Goldman Sachs, an investment bank, and hedge funds.

His wife, Akshata Murty, who he met while studying at Stanford University, is the daughter of one of India’s richest IT entrepreneurs.

Sunak became widely known to the public when he was named by Johnson as chancellor of the Exchequer in 2020. He immediately had to face the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic as the first significant test of his tenure at the helm of the finance ministry.

He became popular for the financial support packages to businesses and workers hit by coronavirus lockdowns, including furloughs, loans for ailing companies and vouchers for restaurant visits – essentially a carte blanche from Johnson.

“Sunak was operating under a prime minister who was keen to spend money, particularly on infrastructure projects designed to deliver the levelling up agenda and more generally because Johnson made spending promises without always considering how to pay for them,” Neil Carter, professor of politics at the University of York, told Al Jazeera.

“But certain actions backfired – the ‘eat out to help out’ initiative may have saved the restaurant sector but almost certainly contributed to the devastating second COVID wave in autumn 2020,” he said.

Johnson was seemingly inclined to let Sunak do the work – arguably to a fault, Stephen Elstub, reader in British politics, told Al Jazeera.

“During the pandemic, when the government was making regular televised briefings, the chancellor announced the government handouts while the prime minister was telling us how many people had died and that we all needed to stay at home,” he said.

With the end of all lockdown restrictions this year, however, Sunak changed his approach towards government debt – just as people began grappling with massive rises in the cost of living.

“His significant increases in corporation tax and national insurance were attacked from across the political spectrum for damaging business, and because national insurance is a tax on workers, so it falls disproportionately on younger people,” Carter said.

Sunak, who was deeply critical of his predecessor’s unfunded tax cuts that plunged the British economy into chaos, campaigned on a pledge that he was the right person to manage the economy.

Critics, however, see it otherwise and will surely say Sunak has no mandate to govern.

Keir Starmer, leader of the main opposition Labour Party, which is leading opinion polls by a wide margin, said last week he was ready to form a government.

“After 12 years of Tory failure, the British people deserve so much better than this revolving door of chaos,” he said on Twitter.

Analysts say Sunak’s lack of mandate means he will have to produce tangible results immediately.

Tom Caygill, lecturer in politics at Nottingham Trent University, said there was a number of issues “waiting for him on his desk”.

“Firstly there is still the fallout from Truss’ mini-budget,” he told Al Jazeera. “The financial markets are looking for stability and confidence. They are also expecting some fiscal restraint too. The latter might be the harder of two things that the markets want as it will likely require spending cuts or tax rises, neither of which will be popular.

“Secondly, he needs to be able to unite a party which has been bitterly divided. That will take time and wounds won’t necessarily heal quickly.”

Many Tories continue to see Sunak as a traitor after triggering the demise of Johnson. At the previous Tory leadership contest involving party members, Truss had beaten Sunak by 81,326 votes to 60,399.

Despite the opposition’s persistent calls for a general election, Sunak on Monday appeared to rule out a snap vote.

“The United Kingdom is a great country, but there is no doubt we face a profound economic challenge,” he said, promising to bring “stability and unity” at a time of economic turmoil.

Caygill said he did not expect an early election. “It isn’t due until December 2024 and given the state of the polling at the moment, it is very unlikely that the Conservatives would call an early one on the basis that right now they would lose and lose badly.”

One scenario that might trigger a general election, he said, would be if Sunak was struggling to govern, such as not being able to pass a budget, but he added: “While the psychodrama in the Conservative Party is likely to continue, I suspect they’ll tiptoe away from the brink on those kind of issues.”

Mark Shephard, senior lecturer in politics at the University of Strathclyde, said the possibility of an early election will depend first and foremost on Sunak being able to garner the support of his own party.

“Unless the party unites, there is enough potential intraparty dissension to make government impossible and an election likely as an exit route,” Shephard said. “However, the party would face huge losses at the polls, so begrudging unity [and] not enough dissension to derail may be more likely if he can hang on, calm things down.”

What seems to speak in Sunak’s favour, meanwhile, is he repeatedly warned during the previous leadership race against the very chaos Truss unleashed on the financial markets with her economic policies. And this is something that his supporters are keen to emphasise, portraying him as a safe option to guide the country at a time of global uncertainty.

“Only time will tell [whether or not Sunak is the right man for the job]. The markets seem to like him more than the alternatives,” Shephard said.

The pound rose 0.15 percent against the United States dollar just moments after Sunak’s win became apparent.

Noting that Sunak is “pro-Brexit and anti-immigration“, Elstub said the new Tory leader “describes himself as a ‘fiscal conservative’ advocating for a small state and low taxes. All of this would put him on the right of the party. However, clearly, he is also a pragmatist”.

Indeed, analysts say Sunak will need to display pragmatism to unite his party and provide much-needed stability in a country that has seen more than its fair share of political drama and economic turmoil in recent years. Otherwise, his tenure could also be limited.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Privacy & Cookies Policy